German visa refusal on lack of proof of ties to home country. Should we appeal for review?

German visa refusal on lack of proof of ties to home country. Should we appeal for review? - House on Green Landscape Against Sky

I am currently living in Germany on Blue Card and receiving a handsome salary. My wife is living in Pakistan. We are a newly married couple. She has registered herself in German Consulate for the family reunion visa but the waiting time to get the appointment is more than a year.

So, we decided to apply for a short-term Schengen visa (alongside waiting for the family reunion appointment date). She applied with all the required documents but got a refusal. The reasons for refusal are "You could not prove sufficient family ties to home country" and "You could not prove sufficient economic ties to home country".

I understand the reasons as stated someone else that She should provide followings:

  1. A steady job with income.
  2. Family ties (kids going to school for example, spouse, etc.).
  3. Property or other assets.
  4. Other similar evidence.

But the problem is,

  1. She does not have any job (no employment relationship).
  2. She is living with my parents and she does not own any house or property (no family ties and no economic bond).
  3. She has finished her last degree and she is not enrolled in any school or university.
  4. She does not have any kids.
  5. She never visited Europe before (no last Schengen-Visa).

In the consideration of the above points, what can she have as a proof to show family and economic ties? What can we write in the appeal to convince that she doesn't have any intension to stay in Germany for more than 90 days as we have already registered for the family reunion visa in the consulate before applying to Schengen Visa?

I believe that from my side and other documents are Okay (we provided all the documents that we can), we just need to provide any document that shows her ties to home country Pakistan. Please guide what documents can we provide. Is it a deadlock for her?






Pictures about "German visa refusal on lack of proof of ties to home country. Should we appeal for review?"

German visa refusal on lack of proof of ties to home country. Should we appeal for review? - Brown Cabin Near Trees and Mountains
German visa refusal on lack of proof of ties to home country. Should we appeal for review? - White and Brown Concrete 2-storey House Near Tree
German visa refusal on lack of proof of ties to home country. Should we appeal for review? - Brown and Beige House and Path



How do I appeal against a German visa refusal?

The applicant may appeal this decision within one month by filing an action with the Administrative Court in Berlin. The applicant also has the option of appealing to the Court (also within one month) against the initial decision instead of remonstrating to the mission.

How do you prove you have strong ties to your home country?

To substantiate your professional roots in your home country, you can use the following evidence:
  • Statement from employer specifying your job duties, length of employment, and salary.
  • Letter written by employer giving you permission to take paid time off.
  • Pay stubs, or other documentation proving your income.


  • What happens if my German residence permit application is rejected?

    If your application is rejected, you will receive a letter outlining the reasons for the refusal. The most common reason for a rejection is failing to provide the correct corroborating documents. The letter will explain the next steps to take, including how to lodge an appeal, if applicable.

    How do I write a letter of appeal for a visa refusal?

    Explain the reasons why your visa was refused, as given in the rejection letter you got from the embassy (if you did) List and explain the reasons why you believe the rejection was incorrect, showing arguments. Do not forget to put your signature at the end of the letter, after you print it.




    Sources: Stack Exchange - This article follows the attribution requirements of Stack Exchange and is licensed under CC BY-SA 3.0.

    Images: Pixabay, Pixabay, Mike B, Lukas Kloeppel