Practical aspects of security when travelling in India

Indian rail suggests that the property lockers in AC class compartments will keep my goods secure. I've heard otherwise. Any advice?

Train travel is usually safe, while traveling in AC compartments. I'd still suggest you to be alert. They don't have lockers per say, but you can use a cable to tie your luggage. Use big locks too. That should be fine for train travel. Always lock your luggage regardless of which transport mode you use. Volvo buses (A.C. buses) and plane - both are safe.

How liable are goods in low cost hotel rooms to be at risk? What degree of security is needed for reasonable peace of mind?

Not too reliable. But, again, this depends on the city you are in. Accommodation isn't dear in India. Try and stay in not so low-cost hotels, if you can. But, if money is a major constraint, carry your valuable goods with you when you go out. Keep your luggage locked in the room, just in case.

I read that luggage lockers are provided at major railway stations. Are these reliably secure?

Yes.

On a side note - are you carrying lots of expensive stuff apart from your camera? India, like any other touristy Asian country, is both safe and unsafe. It all depends on how alert you are. But, don't worry too much. I have traveled extensively in India (never locked my luggage), have traveled by plane, train and bus, and I have never had an issue. Enjoy that beautiful country.

Security is really about accepting risk. You can never remove it all, even with all your preparations.

In India I'm willing to accept more risk, but I try to lower it by not bringing so many expensive things, maybe only a tripod, my old camera and consumer grade lenses with an old laptop for image editing. I try to keep things that I can't easily replace close to me at all times, even in bed when I sleep. My main luggage can mostly be replaced easily so I just relay new delhi shopping malls, travel insurance and my regular alertness.

I have traveled in India many times. I however always stay at places that are respectable (I quickly check the bad reviews on tripadvisor), and I will walk immediately out of any hotel that I don't like. I often walk around and check 2-5 hotels before I decide. Be alert when you are around typically tutor places like transport stations and tourists attractions, but other places my impression is that India is a very safe place, and people are both honest and respectable. Enjoy your trip and accept a little more risk!

I read that luggage lockers are provided at major railway stations. Are these reliably secure?

Last week I faced a similar issue in New Delhi when I came across 'Bagdolo'.

It is a luggage storage or Cloakroom service which allows one to store luggage on hourly basis. Best part is they have storage points near major hubs across Delhi/NCR . It can be booked online. They are quite safe as well.

I have used it twice since then and it's worth recommending !

If I need to sleep in a publicly accessible area (eg dorm or room of uncertain security) I'd planned to have a highly intrusion resistant main bag (mesh or kevlar) attached to me with sensible sized stainless wire. How necessary is this or how substantial do I need such precautions to be?

Security could be inobtrusive or purposefully obvious. (eg stainless wire grid inside bag or outside. "Protected by ..." labels or none. Inobvious systems may be attacked with some damage even if unsuccessful. Obvious systems advertise valuable contents.

If someone wanted to steal your stuff they would very likely just lift the whole bag and deal with the security later. Organised theft is generally unlikely in India except in certain areas. Mostly it is more opportunistic or relatively unorganized, so if you keep your belongings closed to you and stay alert, you should be okay.

If you have a laptop, I would suggest you install Prey security software beforehand.