Literary Pilgrimage to Top Withens, Yorkshire (Wuthering Heights)

Literary Pilgrimage to Top Withens, Yorkshire (Wuthering Heights) - Back view of anonymous male traveler in casual clothes standing on edge of cliff and admiring breathtaking scenery of clouds and mountain top

This summer hundreds (maybe thousands) of tourists and literary pilgrims will make the trek from Haworth to the ruins of Top Withens. For the most part they will start at the Bronte Parsonage and follow the path across the falls, climb the ravine, and join with the Enfield Side Road to reach the ruin.

enter image description here

I wanted to attempt an alternate route that begins at a place I hope this question will identify. The illustration for the 1872 edition of Wuthering Heights is an engraving...

enter image description here

I have used Photoshop to put labels on the three farmhouses. It is known that the artist's depiction of the house called Top Withens is fanciful, and that's not the point. Its location is real and the three farmhouses are known to have existed. Where did the artist (known to be Edward Morison Wimperis) stand? The path commonly used by literary pilgrims does not provide this vantage point.

The foreground of the illustration appears to show an old drove which crosses a country lane. The three farmhouses are shown in a straight line which runs parallel to a dip (possibly a ravine) on the left. But there's no orientation. The view could be from the from the east, or looking north or even looking west. The shadows are wrong for a southern aspect. The ruins of Bottom Withens and Middle Withens are gone by now, at least I cannot find them on Google Maps' satellite view and there is no indication on this marvellous overview provided by Google.

I expect that it is within a two mile radius of Top Withens, but would not have the time or stamina to explore the entire area. I accept that roads and structures may have been built in the intervening 140 years, but still the artist's vantage point should be locatable within a reasonably precise radius.






Pictures about "Literary Pilgrimage to Top Withens, Yorkshire (Wuthering Heights)"

Literary Pilgrimage to Top Withens, Yorkshire (Wuthering Heights) - Unrecognizable backpacker standing on top of mountain
Literary Pilgrimage to Top Withens, Yorkshire (Wuthering Heights) - From above of powerful waterfall falling from rocky cliff in mountainous ravine in highland
Literary Pilgrimage to Top Withens, Yorkshire (Wuthering Heights) - High mountain range reflecting on lake surface under moon shining on clear sky





A Walk to Emily Bronte's Top Withens, Haworth




Sources: Stack Exchange - This article follows the attribution requirements of Stack Exchange and is licensed under CC BY-SA 3.0.

Images: ROMAN ODINTSOV, Dziana Hasanbekava, Nico Becker, Oliver Schmid