Why have they announced to turn off phones while they are explicitly allowed?

Why have they announced to turn off phones while they are explicitly allowed? - Focused woman flipping page of book

Last week I've flown three times through Aerolíneas Argentinas, both in an Airbus A340-300 and in a Boeing 737-800.

In both, the card with the safety instructions explicitly said that cameras and smartphones could be used during every stage of the flight - always in flight mode, of course. It also said that old phones that lacked flight mode capability couldn't be used.

But, during all announcements, the crew insisted they should be turned off for take off.

Why did they say that? Why's that difference?

I wish I had taken a photo of the safety card, but it was really there.



Best Answer

I've heard from informal publications and from crewmembers that there are two reasons. First, the crew needs everyone's undivided attention during takeoff/landing, should things go suddenly wrong. Second, some have said it causes interference.

Based on the first answer, I've often wondered why it's okay to read a book but it's not okay to read from a tablet or computer. I think airline companies or crews just think it's a slippery slope and would rather ban them entirely than make the rules more complicated.

UPDATE:

Many (US) airlines now allow tablets to be used during takeoff/landing provided they are small enough (e.g. less than a certain weight). Check with a specific airline for details.

UPDATE (7 January 2017):

It really depends on the airline and applicable law. The "Mobile phones on aircraft" Wikipedia article has an excellent overview of this. For those of us in the USA, this excerpt from that article may be helpful:

Contrary to popular misconception, the Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) does not actually prohibit the use of personal electronic devices (including cell phones) on aircraft. Paragraph (b)(5) of 14 CFR 91.21 leaves it up to the airlines to determine if devices can be used in flight, allowing use of "Any other portable electronic device that the operator of the aircraft has determined will not cause interference with the navigation or communication system of the aircraft on which it is to be used.

With more people having smartphones, tablets, and the like, and with the increasing popularity of WiFi on airplanes, there appears to be more pressure to allow such devices on aircraft throughout the flight. Still, it appears to be up to the airline to set and enforce their own rules.




Pictures about "Why have they announced to turn off phones while they are explicitly allowed?"

Why have they announced to turn off phones while they are explicitly allowed? - Free stock photo of affection, casual, couple
Why have they announced to turn off phones while they are explicitly allowed? - Cheerful young diverse female friends laughing while watching funny video on smartphone during coffee break in cozy cafe
Why have they announced to turn off phones while they are explicitly allowed? - Group of cheerful young male and female multiracial friends laughing and taking selfie on smartphone while spending time together on terrace



Should mobile phones be turned off?

\u201cIf you run your battery all the way down to zero every once in a while \u2014 once a year is fine \u2014 it makes the percentage count on your battery more accurate,\u201d says Weins. So once a year, not once a week, power your phone off all the way.

Should smartphones be turned off at night?

You almost never have to shut down your mobile devices. If you're shutting down your phone at night thinking you're increasing the battery's lifetime, stop. This is a myth. There's no need to shut down your iPhone, iPad, or Android devices.

Why is turning off your phone important?

Overcharging and overheating can quickly damage your phone's battery and shorten its lifespan. That's why it's important to make sure that your battery remains in good health. Why Do You need to Turn Off Your Phone? Experts suggest that turning your phone off can help preserve your battery for longer.

What smartphones should be avoided?

But the list of top failing Android device models was a little different....Here's the top five:
  • Xiaomi Redmi 4 (9%)
  • Motorola Moto G (5S) Plus (6%)
  • Lenovo Lenovo K8 Note (5%)
  • HMD Global Nokia 6 (4%)
  • Samsung Galaxy S7 (3%)




Jan. 6 committee holds seventh public hearing in series - 07/12 (FULL LIVE STREAM)




More answers regarding why have they announced to turn off phones while they are explicitly allowed?

Answer 2

People sometimes get things wrong. Rules sometimes exist which have no purpose, either because they used to be valid, or because they are a 'cargo cult', or because it is seen as desirable to enforce some form of authority in certain situations, and it doesn't matter what form that authority takes.

People also sometimes find spurious justifications for rules which they don't fully understand or which have no justification. There is a strong resistance in certain cultures to saying 'We know that that rule is nonsense, however, we are going to insist on it anyway.' People are more likely to follow a rule with a made-up justification than a rule which is openly acknowledged to be pointless.

Sources: Stack Exchange - This article follows the attribution requirements of Stack Exchange and is licensed under CC BY-SA 3.0.

Images: George Milton, Karolina Grabowska, Ketut Subiyanto, Kampus Production