Getting from New York JFK airport to Manhattan, without the sneaky airtrain exit fee?
The last time I flew into JFK, I took the "free" AirTrain from the terminal out to the subway. I was rather surprised and annoyed, on getting to the subway transfer, to discover that it wasn't free after all. Between terminals is free, but to transfer to the subway you had to pay a special exit fee of $5. Only after that could you then buy your subway ticket, and head into town. By the time I was at the subway station, it was too late to change plans, so I had to grudgingly pay. They kept this very quiet until you got to the end, and it was too late to change your plans!
For my next trip, I should have more time (I land mid-afternoon, but I'm not meeting friends until after work). I know that with other airports with high charges for the public transport connection, there's often a hidden way to avoid it that locals know. (In Sydney for example, there's a bus that'll take you a couple of miles to a normal railway station, or you can walk just over a mile to another one).
What I'm wondering is if there's something like that for JFK? I'm aiming to get to either lower Manhattan, or Brooklyn Heights. Can I get either to a subway station, or all the way down to somewhere like that, without having to pay the airtrain exit fee? (The subway from out by the airport to Brooklyn/Manhattan is only $2.25, and the current airtrain exit fee is an extra $5, so anything involving private buses/shuttles will likely work out much more!)
Best Answer
The $5 surcharge of the AirTran is only collected at the terminal stops, so when transferring to the Subway or entering the airport. If you're looking to avoid that charge, you can take the AirTran to the car rental exit (at no cost) and hop on the free shuttle bus to Jamaica station. There you can take the E, J or Z which serve southwestern Queens, Brooklyn and lower Manhattan, the LIRR is also at this station for those interested. That shuttle bus has two stops: Jamaica station and Federal Circle Rental Cars stop, so you don't have to worry about missing the right stop or if your bus is going in the right direction, etc.
JFK is horribly designed in that it's not optimized for pedestrians, this way minimizes you having to navigate through the maze.
Pictures about "Getting from New York JFK airport to Manhattan, without the sneaky airtrain exit fee?"
How do I avoid paying AirTrain at JFK?
Here are a few ways:Is JFK AirTrain free between terminals?
The AirTrain system operates between all passenger terminals. For journeys between terminals, it's free. To make your connection, follow signs for AirTrain. You will need to reclear TSA security once you arrive in your departure terminal.How much is the AirTrain from JFK to Manhattan?
Unfortunately none of New York's subway lines will get you from JFK to Manhattan door-to-door, but with the help of the AirTrain you can get yourself into the city (both run 24/7). The cost of an AirTrain ticket is $5 one-way and the subway ride is a flat fee of $2.75.Can I use unlimited MetroCard on JFK AirTrain?
You can use unlimited ride MetroCards and OMNY on the subway but not on the AirTrain.How to get to Manhattan by train from JFK airport | NYC travel guide
More answers regarding getting from New York JFK airport to Manhattan, without the sneaky airtrain exit fee?
Answer 2
Yes, it's totally doable, I walked it on Friday night from Howard Beach subway-A to Airtrain Lefferts Boulevard: ~30min. Nice Christmas houses at Howard Beach, but:
It's much quicker to step down at Aqueduct/Conduit subway-A and walk to Airtrain Lefferts Boulevard. ~20min walking which saves the $5. Depending on the Airtrain/Subway frequency, that might be worth it.
I don't consider it unsafe, just a sidewalk next to a moderate speed way. A little narrow on the bridge entering the airport, but still good to me.
Here are the walking instructions.
Answer 3
In addition to what Choster has described there may be a way to do it without the transfer from Bus to Subway.
There is a long term parking adjacent to the Lefferts Blvd Airtran station and Howard Beach A train station. This used to be serviced by the free shuttle for all the terminals though it was running not as often as others. So if you take that shuttle to Long Term Parking Lot C you could just walk to the Howard Beach A train. One thing to check is whether or not this shuttle runs to the terminal it's possible this was changed it's possible the route is only within the long term lots.
P.S. Personally I try to avoid JFK like a plague
Answer 4
When leaving JFK, get the free Airtrain shuttle to the Lefferts Blvd station stop then get off and get the Q10 bus to Ozone Park Lefferts Blvd subway station where you can get the A train to the city. Transfers are free between bus and subway when you use a metro card. Do the reverse to get to the airport.
Answer 5
You need to make sure that you have a metro card as you can not buy one at Hudson’s or any outlet in JFK. Take the Q10 Bus from T5 going to Kew Gardens union TPK Station.Get off Lefferts Blvd and Cuthbert Rd. From here you can catch the A or C train into Manhattan. If you didn’t have a metro card pay 2.75 on the bus so make sure you have change. This is time consuming but it helps to avoid the Airtrain fee
Answer 6
Just feel like it needs to be stated here that an able and slightly intrepid traveler should also just be able to WALK from the 'Lefferts Blvd' station (the one right before 'Howard Beach') to to regular subway. It's about 20 minutes to the 'Aqueduct/Conduit' station or closer to 30 to 'Howard Beach'. Google maps will show the directions. It's not glamorous, but it's doable.
Answer 7
The best way to save money is going to Terminal 5, take the Q10 LTD bus (Or Local, it's just slower), and then transfer to A Train or E,F Train. Since there is a free transfer for travels less than two hour, you will only have to pay $2.75 in total.
Sources: Stack Exchange - This article follows the attribution requirements of Stack Exchange and is licensed under CC BY-SA 3.0.
Images: Ketut Subiyanto, Charlotte May, Ketut Subiyanto, Ketut Subiyanto