Are there any cultures in which the "thumbs up" hand gesture is offensive?

Are there any cultures in which the "thumbs up" hand gesture is offensive? - Overhead view of crop unrecognizable male with approve gesture on wooden table between American decoration with stripes and stars

In the USA it's common to give a thumbs up to say "Yes, this is good" or "Thanks" or convey another appropriate positive meaning.

Are there cultures in which the "thumbs up" gesture a) would not be understood, or b) would be offensive to the local people?



Best Answer

You can probably use Wikipedia to determine the exact implications of the gesture. From the information:

In Afghanistan, Iran and parts of Italy, the gesture is regarded as an obscene insult equivalent to what the middle finger signifies in most of Europe, especially when combined with a sweep of the arms. In these places, it roughly means "Sit on my phallus" and carries the same stigma as does raising the middle finger in the west. The sign has a similarly pejorative meaning in parts of West Africa, South America, Iran and Sardinia, according to Roger E. Axtell's book Gestures: The Do's and Taboos of Body Language Around the World." In southern Sardinia, where this gesture is noted for being particularly obscene, a hitchhiker would be well advised not to wave his thumb in the air expecting a car to pick him up, or he may find himself under the wheels of a large truck.

Though it states that it may be offensive in Israel I haven't found this to be the case.

EDIT

As per the latest edit to the quoted Wiki page:

The sign has a pejorative meaning in parts of West Africa, Iran, and Greece according to Roger E. Axtell's book Gestures: The Do's and Taboos of Body Language Around the World. In practice, most Greeks nowadays recognize the positive connotation of the sign due to international exposure. Any perceived pejorative meaning of the past is lost in contemporary use. Despite that, the sign is still very rarely used by native Greeks for its positive meaning (and never for the pejorative).

The information may still be subject to change at a later date.




Pictures about "Are there any cultures in which the "thumbs up" hand gesture is offensive?"

Are there any cultures in which the "thumbs up" hand gesture is offensive? - Person Doing Thumbs Up
Are there any cultures in which the "thumbs up" hand gesture is offensive? - An Animation of a Hand Doing Thumbs Up Sign on a Black Background
Are there any cultures in which the "thumbs up" hand gesture is offensive? - Hand Doing a Thumb Up



What culture finds thumbs offensive?

1. Thumbs Up. In Iran, Greece, Russia, Sardinia, and parts of West Africa the thumbs up is as rude as the middle finger is in the UK. So no posing in front of the Parthenon making the thumbs up gesture like a nerdy tourist.

What hand gestures are offensive in different cultures?

10 Common Hand Gestures That Are Rude in Other Countries
  • Some handy precautions. ...
  • Iran: Thumbs-up. ...
  • United Kingdom: Backwards peace sign. ...
  • Malaysia: Pointing with your index finger. ...
  • Brazil: The \u201cOK\u201d sign. ...
  • Italy and Spain: \u201cHang loose\u201d (or the \u201crock on\u201d sign) ...
  • Thailand: Touching someone's head.


What is the most offensive hand gesture?

The middle finger is probably the most obscene gesture in the U.S. The most offensive gesture in America is flipping someone off.

Are thumbs up offensive in Italy?

Thumbs-Up. The thumbs-up signals approval in the U.S. and on Facebook, but in Afghanistan, Iran, parts of Italy, and Greece, it means \u201cup yours.\u201d So next time you're trying to hitchhike in, say, Tuscany, you should reconsider before sticking out your thumb. Avoid Using In: Afghanistan, Iran, parts of Italy, and Greece.



American Hand Gestures in Different Cultures - 7 Ways to Get Yourself in Trouble Abroad




More answers regarding are there any cultures in which the "thumbs up" hand gesture is offensive?

Answer 2

Not offensive, but in Malaysia you use the thumb to point at things (using the index is rude).

So, you would be pointing at the ceiling/sky.

EDIT: If needed, in Malaysia or Indonesia, use the "ring sign" from divers. I can not guaranty this would be understood in the mountain.

EDIT: Of course, if you travel back to ancient Rome, this is an imperial prerogative. Don't do that. Unless you really are Cesar, that is.

Answer 3

Regardless of what cultural norms have been in the past, the meaning of the thumbs-up sign is getting strongly influenced by the Internet. The biggest example is Facebook, which uses the gesture to indicate someone 'likes' a certain post:

facebook like

With this in mind, I would no longer worry about misusing the sign anywhere except the most distant regions without access to the Internet.

Sources: Stack Exchange - This article follows the attribution requirements of Stack Exchange and is licensed under CC BY-SA 3.0.

Images: Brett Sayles, Donald Tong, cottonbro CG, cottonbro CG