Why aren't there cube-shaped suitcases or bags?

Why aren't there cube-shaped suitcases or bags? - A Selection of Vintage Suitcases

This is for check-in baggage, not carry on. A cube would maximise the volume while complying with the 62-inch limit on the length + width + height. It would be 20.7 inches along each side.

It will also be much less likely to fall over.

When placed on a table or a bed in a cramped hotel room, it will take up less space on the table or bed.

A disadvantage will be a great depth, with things packed many layers deep, so you'll have to unpack before you can access things in the lower layers. But I, and I'm sure others, will happily live with this disadvantage.

So, why aren't there such suitcases or bags?



Best Answer

A cube would maximise the volume while complying with the 62-inch limit

Maybe true from a mathematical point of view, but in reality cube suitcases would be:

  • Harder to carry with a handle, you will have to stretch your arm away from your body, which will make things feel heavier.
  • It will be harder to walk while carrying them.
  • What about long objects you can easily put inside the normal suitcases?

It will also be much less likely to fall over

True, if it was the only suitcase. False in reality because it will be harder to place cube suitcases in containers on top of each other, this will make them much more prone to fall causing damage to them or to luggage handlers.

A disadvantage will be a great depth, with things packed many layers deep, so you'll have to unpack before you can access things in the lower layers

This is true for one person, a person will have one or two suitcases, but a customs agent will have a hell of a job because scanners will not be that effective due to the many layers, and manual inspection will be difficult. That's the reason why you have to put your luggage flat when you scan them, to make the scanner more effective. Making luggage condensed by default will be a big problem from security point of view.

When placed on a table or a bed in a cramped hotel room, it will take up less space on the table or bed.

I disagree, whatever space you save on one axis, you will get it in the other axis. Having a normal suitcase along the wall is indeed more space friendly than having a cube shaped suitcase with less space on the wall and much more space away from the wall.




Pictures about "Why aren't there cube-shaped suitcases or bags?"

Why aren't there cube-shaped suitcases or bags? - A Selection of Vintage Suitcases
Why aren't there cube-shaped suitcases or bags? - Unrecognizable travelers with baggage walking on city roadway
Why aren't there cube-shaped suitcases or bags? - Black suitcase with stickers placed on table



Are packing cubes any good?

Absolutely! Packing cubes are a great help in multiple ways during the packing and traveling process. Firstly, they help contain your clothes into a more compact space. Since all your clothes are zipped up into the cube, you can easily move them around while packing and have them fit neatly into your suitcase.

Why are all the suitcases sold out?

The Points Guy reported that a raw materials shortage, lack of truck drivers, and increased travel demand have all contributed to the shortage, resulting in stores like Macy's, Bed Bath & Beyond, and Target lacking in the luggage department.

What is the shape of luggage bag?

A suitcase is a form of luggage. It is often a somewhat flat, rectangular-shaped bag with rounded square corners. Vinyl, leather or cloth suitcases may have a metal frame.

Do packing cubes add weight?

If you're paying more solely for the reason that they're lightweight, probably not. A set of regular packing cubes usually weighs similar to the weight of a hoodie, and lightweight cubes are identical to the weight of a regular t-shirt.



Why Aren't These Everywhere? // Sequential Take 5 // Six Month User Review




More answers regarding why aren't there cube-shaped suitcases or bags?

Answer 2

Balikbayan boxes, popular among Filipinos for bringing goods home when flying, are indeed quite close to cubic. Standard sizes are:

  • Medium: 18 × 16 × 18 inches
  • Large: 18 × 18 × 24 inches
  • Extra large: 24 × 18 × 24 inches

While they are optimized for shipping, they are unwieldy for travel. In addition to issues mentioned in other answers…

  • A cube does not offer choices of orientation for optimal packing into the trunk of a car.
  • The wide footprint would prevent you from wheeling it onto an escalator (if it had wheels).

Answer 3

@Robert points it out, they would be too unwieldy. Although you, as a passenger, would have not to worry about them while being transported by plane, you still would have to get them from your home to the airport. And that's assuming that's the only moving around you'll do. Will they have wheels and a long leash so that you can drag them around behind you? If you'd pick it up, you'd have to half outstretch your arm, which won't be easy for many.

That said, somewhat close are things like this:

http://www.amazon.com/Plastic-Checkered-Storage-Laundry-Shopping/dp/B00MI9T7AA

Answer 4

Because they are too unwieldy when you carry it on your side. And it's easy to exceed the weight limits. I already can cram 23 kg in a single large luggage bag.

You can vacuum pack your clothes to make the most of the space in a luggage. Did you want to maximise your luggage space and thought cube shaped luggage might be a solution?

Answer 5

There is nothing stopping you buying the most cube shaped luggage you can find or have made and take it with you. I have seen 'classic' suitcases that are almost square, that used to be transported on ships. They are known, among other names, as cabin trunks.

The full size ones will be too big for nowadays flights, but you can get half size replicas and smaller ones.

They went out of fashion when people had to carry their own luggage, but you can revive the trend.

Answer 6

The other, rather important point is this: While that would indeed give you the maximum volume allowed, packing pretty much anything that fills the maximum volume is likely to take you well, well over weight. It's easy enough to take a bag of a much smaller volume and go over the 18/20/30kg included weight limits. Extra weight gets expensive very fast, and if the bag is too heavy then the airlines may refuse to take it at all.

Sources: Stack Exchange - This article follows the attribution requirements of Stack Exchange and is licensed under CC BY-SA 3.0.

Images: Engin Akyurt, Engin Akyurt, Trần Long, Erik Mclean