Carry on baggage size: With 9'' depth limit are 9.5'' deep bags now too big?
Several observations:
Nearly all major airlines have reduced the allowed depth for carry on bags to 9 inches (eg. JetBlue, United, Delta).
A huge percentage of carry on luggage I see at the airport is greater than 9 inches deep.
- For example, I currently travel with a Tumi Alpha 2 bag which is advertised as 9 inches deep but in practice has a depth greater than 9 inches. (And I used to travel with an even larger bag.)
I rarely see carry-on bags greater than 9 inches deep getting stopped by gate agents on A320s, 757s etc...
In general, is it now a problem to get a 9.5 inch deep carry-on bag on JetBlue?
Do the rules tend to be enforced differently on men and women, taller and shorter people?
What motivated this question is that I travel approximately 30,000-50,000 miles a year for many years and have NEVER been questioned on the size of my carry-on luggage. I have NEVER been asked to put my luggage in a luggage gauge.
In contrast, my girlfriend flies far less frequently but has been stopped by JetBlue twice in her last four flights and told to stick her bag in the luggage gauge to measure its size! (This has only happened when she's traveling alone.)
- The first time was by a JetBlue employee in Boston prior to security (and who appeared to only be stopping unaccompanied females).
- The other time was by a 30 something male JetBlue gate agent in Boston who took my girlfriend's bag but proceeded to let much larger bags onto the Airbus A320.
My girlfriend's bag is a Victorinox, Werks Traveler 5.0 Global Carry On bag, and is almost the identical size as mine (hers is the blue bag, mine is the black bag):
.
If you measure both bags, they're somewhere between 9 and 10 inches deep and easily fit in the overhead compartment of A320s, B757s.
Clearly anecdote isn't carefully collected, unbiased data, but I'd love to know what other experienced travelers have observed.
Is my experience an outlier / is hers?
My impression is that airlines have made a huge share of carry-on luggage against the rules. How consistently does JetBlue enforce its rules?
Best Answer
Given the diverse nature of airline staff, I highly doubt there was any 'profiling' going on.
If your GF is a less than frequent traveler, it may have been the case that she's is boarding near the end of the queue, when overhead space is becoming scarce. Was she also encumbered with other items beyond what would fit under the seat such as a coat, large handbag, etc?
Gate Agents tend to be much more hawkish in the winter.
Pictures about "Carry on baggage size: With 9'' depth limit are 9.5'' deep bags now too big?"
What happens if your bag is too big for carry-on?
In short, if your carry-on is too large, you'll have to pay to check it at the gate. You'll find the exact rules for a large selection of airlines below, including specific size and weight limits. Take note: any handles and wheels on your bags count toward airlines' size limits.Did carry-on luggage size change?
Here's the deal: I.A.T.A. recently announced guidelines for carry-on baggage, promoting a new luggage size of 21.5 inches by 13.5 inches by 7.5 inches, smaller than the 22-by-14-by-9 limit used by most travelers.Is bigger carry-on too big?
While the regular Away Carry-On will pass nearly all regulations, the size of The Bigger Carry-On is also going to be an issue for some airlines. At 22.7 x 14.7 x 9.6 inches (compared to the standard's 21.7 x 13.7 x 9 inches), the dimensions of The Bigger Carry-On exceed many airlines' restrictions by just a hair.Is 26 inches too big for carry-on?
Airlines often specify that a carry-on bag may not exceed 45 linear inches (length plus width plus height).New guidelines proposed for size of carry-on luggage
Sources: Stack Exchange - This article follows the attribution requirements of Stack Exchange and is licensed under CC BY-SA 3.0.
Images: Gustavo Fring, Egor Kamelev, Gustavo Fring, Gustavo Fring